Tall Buildings Cranes

How transparent are large infrastructure projects in Aotearoa?

Transparency within large publicly funded New Zealand infrastructure projects

<p>It’s not easy for the public to see how large, public infrastructure projects in New Zealand are performing, with key project documents often being not publicly available or hard to understand.</p>
<p>This research looks at the accessibility of key documents for 27 large projects across central and local government. These range in cost from $50m to more than $1b and have a collective value of over $70b. These do not just relate to current projects: they span a wide timeframe - for example, one project began construction in 2012 and 21 projects are still ongoing.</p>
<p>While large, public infrastructure projects are subject to normal official information processes, web and plain language standards, they‘re not required to proactively publish key documents. This research showed that around half of all the Business Case and Assurance Case documents in these big, public projects were not accessible, and that reviews were not accessible for completed projects. When project activities and decisions are transparent, New Zealanders are better able to hold government and delivery agencies to account.</p>
<p>We commissioned Massey University to conduct this research.</p>
<h2>Key findings</h2>
<ul>
<li>The study gave projects overall ratings out of nine for accessibility of their project documents. For key documents, 37% of projects scored nine out of nine, while 63% scored only three to five.</li>
<li>All of the highest-scoring projects were run by an independent board, rather than by a government agency or council, and nearly all were in the $500m plus project category.</li>
<li>Projects greater than $500m in value outperformed projects between $50m and $500m in value across all areas assessed for accessibility.</li>
<li>Having a board or a big budget didn’t always mean key documents were ‘accessible’. Because, of the study’s 17 low-scoring projects, 41% also had a board and 23% were in the $500m plus project category.</li>
<li>Accessing information about infrastructure projects was time-consuming and the accessibility of key documents was poor overall. 55.5% of business case documents and 51.8% of assurance plan documents were inaccessible.</li>
</ul>

It’s not easy for the public to see how large, public infrastructure projects in New Zealand are performing, with key project documents often being not publicly available or hard to understand.

Transparency within large publicly funded New Zealand infrastructure projects | Te Waihanga

Document

Terms of use

Privacy policy

Our work

Research & insights

Infrastructure priority list

Project support

Leadership & learning

Reviews

Submissions & advice

Performance monitoring

National Infrastructure Plan

Testing our thinking

About the Plan

Supporting information

The Pipeline

Search the Pipeline

Pipeline snapshot

About the Pipeline

Contribute to the Pipeline

Downloadable data

Understanding market capacity

About us

Our team

Careers

Corporate documents & official information

Get in touch

News & Events

Footer Logo1

Logo 2

Watch & listen

LinkedIn

Facebook

https://www.twitter.com/tewaihanga

Twitter

Highway traffic

City Above

Infrastructure Priorities Programme

City Rail Link Precinct+1+Nov+2017

Group Workshop

man-walking-bridge

Tower Frame

Sunset Couple Walking Landscape

Makara Wind Farm Energy

The Strategy

Our Work

Basket Ball

Feedback on draft National Infrastructure Plan

Train On Hill

Busy Motorway

Highway Harbour Birdeye

Pipeline Banner (1)

Subrub Road Morning Birdeye

Women Construction Talking

Hawkes Bay Napier City Dusk

Cones On Truck

Istock 1340381603

People Standing Hallway Sharing Ideas

Man Cycling Bridge Sunset

Person Walking On Bridge Sunset

News & events

You are already registered.

By entering your email you're registering to receive our monthly newsletter. From time-to-time we may also send relevant infrastructure related news.