Planning a reviewBackground Ida (2)

Planning a review

How to plan, request and complete an IDA Point Review

Investment Decision Assurance (IDA) Point Reviews follow a structured process from planning and requesting a review through to receiving the final findings.

Agencies should plan their reviews early and work backwards from the investment decision the review is intended to inform.

Plan your review

IDA Point Reviews are aligned to key decisions across the investment lifecycle. Before requesting a review, agencies should identify which Point Review is required and make sure the investment evidence is sufficiently developed for the decision being sought.

Agencies should familiarise themselves with the agency agreement and its terms and conditions.

The level of evidence expected is proportionate to the scale, complexity, risk and maturity of the investment. Read the relevant workbook for the required information

When planning the timing of a review, allow for three key timeframes:

At least 4 weeks before the review starts

Request the review and allow time to confirm the review arrangements and provide the required information.

8 weeks for the IDA review

A standard Point Review is designed to take eight weeks. This excludes public holidays and the Christmas and New Year shutdown. Late or incomplete information can delay the review.

Complete the review at least 6 weeks before ministerial or Cabinet consideration
The review must be completed at least six weeks before the earlier of a planned ministerial or Cabinet consideration or decision.

Agencies should plan backwards from their expected decision date when scheduling an IDA review.

Timeline

The review process

The IDA review process takes 8 weeks.

Agencies initiate an IDA review through the Commission.

The Commission drafts an Assurance Plan showing the expected timing of IDA reviews across the investment lifecycle and agrees it with the agency’s Senior Responsible Owner. Agencies should check the plan and provide any updates when requesting a review.

We will work with you to confirm the review arrangements, the information required and your review start date.

If you need help requesting a review or accessing the platform, get in touch: IDA@tewaihanga.govt.nz

Submit the business case or other investment documents and supporting evidence required for your Point Review through the online platform by the agreed Review Start Date.

Evidence does not necessarily need to be prepared as separate documents. Review Teams may draw on business cases, project documentation, supporting analysis and information gathered through interviews.

Agencies should make sure the evidence is sufficiently mature to support the decision the review is intended to inform.

You can find out more about the required evidence for each Point Review in the relevant workbook.

At the start of the review, we check whether your submission contains the information needed to proceed. This is called triage. If we request further information, you must provide it within three working days unless we agree otherwise. Delays may affect the review timetable.

Early in the review, the IDA team engages with the Senior Responsible Owner and relevant members of the investment team.

This helps confirm the context for the investment, identify any emerging issues or areas requiring particular attention, and prepare for interviews.

The independent Review Team assesses the documents against the criteria in the relevant Point Review workbook. It identifies areas to explore further through interviews.

IDA reviews use both document review and interviews to form an evidence-based assessment. They are designed to support professional judgement rather than operate as a checklist or compliance exercise.

The Review Team interviews the Senior Responsible Owner, project team and other relevant stakeholders to test the evidence, understand different perspectives and explore key risks and issues.

The agency helps arrange interviews and ensures the relevant people are available. We keep the Senior Responsible Owner informed as findings develop.

Following the evidence review and interviews, the Review Team develops the draft report.

The report brings together the Review Team’s assessment and provides:

  • an overall IDA review outcome
  • ratings across the six key focus areas
  • recommendations to strengthen the investment or its delivery.

An example of the review report is available below.

The draft report goes through review and quality assurance before it is provided to the agency.

The agency has three working days from receipt of the draft report to identify factual errors, including missing context or documentation relevant to factual accuracy. This is not an opportunity to challenge the independent findings, recommendations or ratings.

We consider the requested corrections and supporting evidence before finalising the report.

We issue the final report once factual corrections have been considered and the report has been approved for release.

The report provides independent advice to inform investment decisions. It does not approve the investment. The overall review outcome will be one of:

  • Proceed
  • Proceed with action
  • Pause and revise
  • Stop or revert.

The investment agency remains accountable for planning, decision-making, delivery and achieving the intended benefits of the investment.

The agency must prepare an Action Plan explaining how it will respond to each recommendation and submit it to us for review and comment. We monitor progress on essential and urgent recommendations and report their status to the Treasury three months after the review.

If the outcome is Pause and revise or Stop or revert, additional follow-up requirements apply. The Senior Responsible Owner must submit the agency’s Action Plan within 20 working days of receiving the Commission’s first notification under the enhanced notification process. We will follow up on progress within three months of the original review. An Assurance of Action Plan review may be used to assess whether the plan satisfactorily addresses the review recommendations.

Review process timeline